Unbalanced Claims

Unbalanced Claims

A common rejection is for Unbalanced Claims. Payments and Adjustments do not equal Charge.

  • If an Encounter is unbalanced or missing the Primary Insurance adjudication, the Claim will not batch.
  • The Primary Payment on the Claim must be posted correctly before it can be batched to send to the Clearinghouse, or the line items that do not balance must be excluded from the Secondary Claim.

Calculation Logic

When an electronic Secondary Claim is created, there is an ANSI loop that represents an EOB.

If one or more of the Encounters do not have a Primary Payment where the sum of IP, CO, and PR codes sum to the total line item Charge, it is rejected as not balanced.

  • Calculation for balancing: Payment + Contractual Adjustment + Other Adjustments + Patient Responsibility = Charge amount
  • Example:
  • Charge =70.00
  • IP = 33.81
  • CO45 = 26.00
  • CO237 = .88
  • CO253 = .69
  • PR2 = 8.62
  • Calculation: IP    +    CO45CO237CO253PR2Charge Amount
  •                      33.8126.00.88     +     .69   +  8.62  = 70.00
  • In the Claim Submission Queue, the unbalanced claims will display in Adjudication Unbalanced line.


Resolve the Unbalanced Line Item(s)

The fix depends on the reason the Claim is unbalanced.

  • Select the number in the Encounters column to correct each one.

  • A Message will be displayed on the Encounter Dashboard in the Balance panel above the Transactions stating why it is unbalanced.
  • The line item that is unbalanced will be highlighted on the Encounter Dashboard.

No Primary Payment Posted on One or More Line Items

  • If the Claim is partially paid or denied entirely, the unbalanced status could be a result of one of these scenarios:
  • Nothing was posted on the denied line items; or
  • The denied line items are posted as a Notes.

Resolution:

  • Use Post Expert to post the zero payments and adjustments on the unpaid line; or
  • Exclude the unpaid lines on the Secondary Claim.
  • This results in the line items with no posted Payments staying in Primary responsibility, and the lines with Payments being sent to the Secondary Payer.


Insurance was changed after Payment

  • The Claim may be unbalanced If a Payment was posted on a previously Active Insurance.
  • Scenario: Insurance Profile on Encounter 123456 was Aetna/Medicaid/Patient.
  • Aetna Payment was received and posted.
  • Later, the Insurance Profile was changed to Anthem/Medicaid/Patient, and the Encounter was mistakenly moved to this new Profile.
  • When the attempt was made to send the Claim to Medicaid, the Secondary Payer, it did not batch and was statused as unbalanced.

Resolution:

  • Batch the Claim again to send to the Secondary Payer.

Payer Adjustments

Sometimes, unusual CARC Codes (Adjustments) can cause Claims to be unbalanced.
  1. To correct this, create the ERA Management Rule "Charge=Allowed-Adjustments does not Equal $0" with the following criteria:
    1. Claim Types: Primary [1], Primary Forwarded [19]

    2. Criteria

      1. Event: Charge - Allowed - Adjustments does not Equal $0

      2. Exclude CARC from Unbalanced Calculation: Enter the CARC Code(s) that is causing the problem, such as: COA2,CO223,CO253,CO144,OA253,PI253,CO237 (No spaces between Codes, use commas to separate)

      3. Action: Put on Hold

        1. This ensures that any other CARC codes/adjustments that were not included will still trigger the rule and go on hold for further review.

      • Remit Note: Enter a note (optional).

      • Additionally, Modify the System Setting ADJBALEXCL to include Manually Posted Payments.

      • If neither of these solutions resolve the problem, review the line items to ensure the ERA was applied correctly and the funds balance.

      • If the Claim is still unbalanced, contact Support.

    • Related Articles

    • Daily Charges Report

      The Daily Charges Report is a detailed breakdown of each Patient's Charges for a day or a date range. This report can be run at the end of the day to capture your Charges, or it can be run for a different period to report Charges and Payments for the ...
    • Payments System Settings

      Payments ADJBALEXCL - EXCLUDE CODES FROM ADJUDICATION BALANCED CALCULATION A calculation is performed when manually posting payments to confirm that the payment is balanced. The "does it balance" calculation is: Charge-Allowed-Adjustments=0 If the ...
    • Claims Management Dashboard

      Claims Management Dashboard Overview Claims can be manually batched and uploaded at any time, or the Job Scheduler can be used to automate the Claims batching and upload process at a pre-set day and time. Close the Reference Batches with Claims that ...
    • Payments & Adjustments Report

      Use this report to find details on any transaction posted by User, date range, time, etc. Example: You notice on your Practice Analysis report that your Adjustments are unusually high. On the Payments & Adjustments Report, you can see exactly what ...
    • Payments, Receipts, and Escrow Overview

      Receipt vs. Payment information The System is an Encounter/Charge based Accounting System. Receipts and Payments are fundamentally different. The Receipt holds the details of the money received, who the Payer is, how much was deposited in the bank. A ...